Yes, it WAS Mapleshade's Fault that her Kits Drowned by I mean, it makes sense conceptually at least; if StarClan is cat-paradise, then it makes logical sense to have an opposite of paradise: a cat-hell where bad cats go when they die. 674 takers Report. Darkstar denied Mapleshade a place in RiverClan, which fueled her anger even more. It was a plump, juicy one, and I had to resist eating it greatly. I dont want your fat, greedy self eating this precious piece of prey.. Since the day he was born, sheacted as a second ghostly voice in Tigerkit's head, not revealing herself until late into his adulthood in a dream. She was apprenticed to Bloomheart and later became a warrior known as Mapleshade. Me too! Larchkit exclaimed. Mapleshade has kits with a Riverclan tom, Appledusk, and lies about it to the clan. I'm going to make you pay for every blessing StarClan gave you! During the battle between the Clans, StarClan and the Dark Forest, she tried to kill a ThunderClan senior warrior, Sandstorm, becauseshe had everything Mapleshade ever wanted: a mate who loved her, having kits that she could watch grow up and one day have kits of their own, and respect from her Clanmates, all of which she believed StarClan stole from her. Frecklewish asks if Birchface, Frecklewish's brother, the warrior who Appledusk killed, is their father. Why a cat would hate StarClan so much that they would rather spend their time wandering alone, hungry and unhappy in the dark seems a bit illogical to me though. to be fair more than half of arc 4 suffers from continuity errors and really badly inserted plot devices (looking at you, fourth cat and hollyleaf). Mapleshade when she joins the Dark Forest. I just was so overwhelmed with all the judging everyone has done of my kits. Mapleshade | Villains Wiki | Fandom According to one of the authors, Vicky Holmes these were actually hallucinations caused by Mapleshade's grief and feelings of betrayal, which drove her mad. Ashfur fully intended to murder both Firestar (by his own admission) and Squirrelflights kits. The Wishful Nights - Book 1: Assassin's Oath. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! Im not sure about being as tall as the trees, but I know your heart is bigger than any tree I have ever seen., Petalkit bounced happily. Be patient, and you will find out everything. Why the Dark Forest makes no sense : r/WarriorCats - reddit Then Sandstorm chases Mapleshade to the border and comes back. And, the most unfair thing of all was that Featherwhisker kept Bluestars secret a secret, when the other medicine cat couldnt keep their snout in the right place, resulting in Mapleshades kits death, heartbreak, and grief. I really like your analysis! Then cats like Darkstripe and Hawkfrost would have gone to the Dark Forest to be with Tigerstar (although they may have also viewed StarClan as weak. 5 Cats That Everyone Thinks Deserved to go to the Dark Forest but dont (and one Cat who Absolutely does) by HollyleafTheGreat, Skye [Skypaw//Skymist//Misty Moon On A Fareway Sky//Has two fanfics going on! Mapleshade's Kits Chapter 1, a warriors fanfic | FanFiction This is a Fanfiction written by Starlingclaw the NightWing. But, I still dont feel like this theory is very strong. In the eyes of StarClan, though, what Mapleshade did was nothing worth banning her to the Dark Forest - she loved a cat from another Clan, and the kits died accidentally. Your Clanmates are lying injured in camp yet you sneak off and risk your life to save a warrior who can't even outrun a Twoleg! Mapleshade killed to avenge her Oakstar should have gone to DF like exiling a queen and kits really dude. The kits soon were playfighting with a leaf that spiraled down from the sky. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. It's worth putting up with him for now, if he can do the same for us. However, when her kits were picked up from the river by a RiverClan patrol, Ravenwing realized who their real father was after receiving an omen with three reeds floating in a small stream that appeared in his den. Imagine how she would've reacted if she'd gone to StarClan instead of the Dark Forest, since she'd be re-united with her kits. I dont remember if it was raining, or if it were flooding season for the river, but many people say Oakstar would have known, and to that I say so would Mapleshade. I already asked Oakstar, and he said it was okay. Warriors: The Return Of The Greatest Heroes - 44. Hollyleaf's Expecting I will never forget this. She is pregnant with his kits, and when she gives birth, Frecklewish assumes theyre her brother, Birchfaces, because no living cat claims them and Birchface has died at the paws of Appledusk. Frecklewish used Mapleshade's kits to feel better about her brother's death and when that didn't work out she wanted them gone in spite of the warrior code. A fresh fish, straight from the river! Appledusk plucks it down in front of the kits. What is going on here? My mother sounded confused, anxious, and concerned at the same time. "Huh," Larchkit says. Yes, it WAS Mapleshade's Fault that her Kits Drowned by HollyleafTheGreat Fan Articles November 2, 2020 59 comments 4 min read HollyleafTheGreat takes a look at Mapleshade's involvement in the death of her kits. However, on the way there, the river suddenly flooded and her kits were swept away. Enter a Melbet promo code and get a generous bonus, An Insight into Coupons and a Secret Bonus, Organic Hacks to Tweak Audio Recording for Videos Production, Bring Back Life to Your Graphic Images- Used Best Graphic Design Software, New Google Update and Future of Interstitial Ads. My name is Mapleshade. These traumatic events left a huge mark on Mapleshade. Frequently, the blame falls on everyone but Mapleshade. Mapleshade Stories - Wattpad Pigma Micron Archival Ink pens. -kept it a secret His apprentice, Perchpaw, attacked Mapleshade and gave her wounds that would later on end her life. Mapleshade watched them elatedly, her heart about to bust with love. Second, the stepping stones are not the safest way to cross, and the map shows two perfectly good bridges that she could have used to cross. Mapleshade's kits are not among StarClan's kits, according to the text. Mapleshade is a large, thick-furred,tortoiseshell-and-white she-cat with amber eyes, anda long, thick, fluffy, white tail. Mapleshade is a sturdy, large, matted, sleek, tortoiseshell she-cat with a scar on the bridge of her nose, a fluffy white tail, and amber eyes. Maybe it's just a matter of how many times you broke the warrior code and how serious these breaks are?Like with Mapleshade, she broke the code like 5 times in the novella I believe and 3 of those times were murder one of which is a medicine cat at the High Stones a place where cats really shouldn't be fighting and especially not killing. The ones that deserve to go to the dark Forest are Oakstar, Appledusk, & Darkstar. 2. I started to take it over to the medicine cat den, but someone interrupted me. Momma, whos that? Patchkit asked quietly. But with Firestar it's more indirect so I doubt it would count against him that much considering that's the worse he actually did. So what? She traps his apprentice as bait, and just when she's trying to get him to fight her, his new mate Reedshine shows up. He told you to wait. Did you find the Horsetail?. I'm not trying to say here that I think Mapleshade should be in StarClan, or that her actions are better than Ashfur's (they're not because she actually did kill cats while Ashfur didn't.) Only if you want to, though., Mapleshade was bewildered, but honored. Mapleshade still felt a sickening in her stomach as she went back to camp. Much, much more lies ahead of us, Tigerclaw. She takes her kits across the river, but they drown. She trusts me now, and I'm so close to the truth! Upon taking her and the kit's bodies to RiverClan camp, Appledusk blamed Mapleshade for crossing the river which resulted in the kit's deaths, and rejected her in front of his Clan. She was able to keeptheir relationship a secret, until she gave birth to their kits. Because of the murders she committed, Mapleshade's spirit was denied entry to StarClan and instead sent to the Place of No Stars, also known as the Dark Forest. If you are going to edit a lot, then make yourself a user and login. In her desperation to get her kits to safety, Mapleshade tried to take themacross the river to seek refuge in RiverClan. Hawkfrost almost destroyed an enetire clan and was on the same path as tigerstar, he was ready to kill without mercy.I feel like thats enough to go to hell, 2)Hollyleaf didnt go to the dark forest because she was able to make up for what she did, and she faught to the death for her clan instead of the dark forest, 3)Ashfur didnt pretend to feel bad but starclan gives us the reason he went there.he did what he did out of love.I dont think that justifys anything but thats the reason, 4)Crowfeathers sidequest kind of shows us that you dont choose, he was almost killed and woke up in the dark forest, but he didnt choose to go there and was afraid until ashfur came and asked what the heck was going on with him, All in all i think the concept of starclan and the darkforest are pretty akin to our own, if your evil you go to hell, if your good you go to heaven, About your 1) point, my intention was never to argue that any cat in the Dark Forest was a good cat, who didn't deserve to be in the Dark Forest, just to point out there is no defined metric as to why cats go to the Dark Forest, beyond a nebulous sense of "oh, well they're bad.". honestly, I'll never understand why Ashfur wasn't in the Dark Forest. Mapleshade Once she left, I grabbed the mouse and took it back to Crimsonwish. The following night, she waits at Highstones and kills Ravenwing at the Moonstone. Patchyface, thats my prey, because I caught it. Ready to build her army. I always thought of it as the cat you are in your heart. 1. The river borrowed through the territories like a weaving snake, letting nothing get in its way. "He loved too much". This is due to the fact that,unlike most of the other major villains, whose evil actions are driven by a lust for something they've never had, Mapleshade's evil actions are driven by grief and anger over something she has lost. She became obsessed with seeking vengeance for her kits' deaths and achieved this by killing Ravenwing, Frecklewish, and Appledusk, but not before being fatally wounded by Perchpaw, Appledusk's apprentice. But you have not won, Mapleshade. Mapleshade is one of thefewmajor female villains in the. Mapleshade watched as the three kits ran up to sniff it. Honestly, Mapleshade's actions make more sense than Ashfur's in that context because she actually killed the cats that had a direct hand in causing her exile/the kits' death, while Ashfur intended to murder Firestar, Jayfeather, Hollyleaf, and Lionblaze, all cats who never did anything to cause direct harm to him. Mapleshade could never make the Clans suffer enough for what had been done to her. You have betrayed me and my kits. Mapleshades thoughts were interrupted by a groan. Mapleshade's kits survive the journey to RiverClan and grow up in the new Clan. After his death, Tigerstar joined Mapleshade in the Dark Forest. I believe we will make it to the Half-Moon Meeting. Ashfur, however, is a bit more complicated he never actually breaks the code he's only ever given the chance to make threats to murder in the case of trying to murder Jayfeather and his siblings. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. After RiverClan cast her out of the scene, Mapleshade went into grief and hallucinated of her dead kits crying out to be avenged. Mapleshade tries to stop them talking, but Ravenwing reveals he had a omen, and thinks it's about the kits, that the kits do not belong in ThunderClan. Great article, you really are HollyleafTheGreat! Deathberries come from the dark-leaved yew bush and can be characterized by their bright red color. Why does every single second everyone spends is inspecting my kits?!?! Mapleshadebravely triedto save her kits, and almost drowned herself in doing so, but ultimately failed. Greystripe was killings in battle, 2 . But instead she chose to be lazy and take the fastest and most dangerous way, even if there was no flood. Why?! Thanks! They can kill a cat in seconds. Thanks, I whispered, smiling. Mapleshade watched them, amused and satisfied. The kits soon were playfighting with a leaf that spiraled down from the sky. This list shows the victims Mapleshade has killed: Warriors Wiki is a FANDOM Books Community. Mapleshade | The Official Warrior Cats Wiki | Fandom You will live to regret this day forever, ThunderClan, and that is a promise. Mapleshade uncomfortably agrees, knowing that Appledusk is their real father. Thank you! Mapleshade gives her news to the Clan the next day, and when asked about the father she says only that she's raising the kits alone. Consider creating an account! Another reason why she shouldve not gone to the dark forest was when she was training Crookedstar. Why do you think I'm here?.Mapleshade to Crookedstar. If he was the medicine cat, why does he need me? You now know the truth about everything, as well as not being murdered by Appledusk; you just fell in the river. And Mapleshade was having nightmares of her kits unable to reach starclan without killing appledusk, ravenwing, And frecklewish. Enraged, Mapleshade attacked and killed Spottedleaf, causing her to fade away forever. Yeah, I think that they(dead cats) can make up rules as they go. Appledusk and Mapleshade sat together, watching from afar while their kits ate the fish. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This has too many spoilers, Why cant I stop reading Blogclan?! By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. I have walked beside you from the day you were born, guiding your paw steps, laying out your destiny before you. HollyleafTheGreat takes a look at Mapleshades involvement in the death of her kits. The Ultimate Guide: Updated and Expanded Edition, Mapleshade & Crookedstar - Mini Collector Figures, Mapleshade and Appledusk's confrontation, Mapleshade's confrontation with Spottedleaf. But, there is still one glaring example that trashes this whole theory anyway: Ashfur. She kept their relationship a secret, sneaking out at night to meet him in private. I thought I would examine some examples of cats who we know what their lives were like, and why they went to the Dark Forest or not after they died, and show how there seems to be no consistent rule about who goes there. Mapleshade, however, bested him in single combat and made an impression upon him by revealing her tragic past. Do you make that promise?.Mapleshade demanding Crookedkit's fateful promise.